The votes are in! We’re thrilled to share that Cruise Critic members have recognized Disney’s private island in the Bahamas, Castaway Cay, as the “Best Cruise Line Private Island” in its Cruisers’ Choice Destination Awards.

Cruise Critic Members Name Disney’s Castaway Cay the Best Cruise Line Private Island

But that’s not all! Castaway Cay also came out on top as the most highly-ranked island by its members among all Caribbean categories – best Eastern, Western and Southern Caribbean islands.

Cruise Critic Members Name Disney Castaway Cay the Best Cruise Line Private Island

Cruise Critic’s Cruise Choice Destination Awards is the first-ever destination focused awards based exclusively on member ratings submitted with reviews on the Cruise Critic website. For more information and a full list of Cruisers’ Choice Destination Awards winners, be sure to check out CruiseCritic.com.

Cruise Critic Members Name Disney Castaway Cay the Best Cruise Line Private Island

So tell us, what do you think makes Disney Castaway Cay the best of the best in your book?